Potbelly Sandwich Shop Prices in New York, New York

4.4 based on 523 votes
Cuisine
Sandwiches

Hours

  • Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop is the kind of fast food sandwich shop where you can just walk in when you are hungry and come out without regrets. The main grilled sandwich is grilled, with the bread pressed until crunchy and the filling is adequate-classic turkey, pepperoni, or vegetarian options, and you can add their signature mushroom sauce. The store is not big, the decoration has a retro tone, the music is often played loudly, and the atmosphere is very casual. In addition to sandwiches, milkshakes and cookies are also worth taking along. Suitable for one person to quickly settle lunch, or have a simple meal with friends without putting on airs.

Order Online

Order from official channels or delivery partners.

Official website

Location

Menu prices may vary by location.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu

Sandwiches

  • Clubby

    $7.25

    Big

  • Italian

    $6.10

    Big

  • Turkey Breast

    $6.00

    Big

  • Smoked Ham

    $6.00

    Big

  • Grilled Chicken Mediterranean

    $7.40

    Big

  • Tuna Salad

    $6.00

    Big

  • Pizza Sandwich

    $6.40

    Big

  • A Wreck

    $6.40

    Big

  • Grilled Chicken

    $6.60

    Big

  • Roast Beef

    $6.00

    Big

  • Mediterranean

    $6.40

    Big

  • Chicken Salad

    $6.00

    Big

  • Meatball

    $6.00

    Big

  • Vegetarian

    $6.00

    Big

Salads

  • Chicken Salad Salad

    $6.45

  • Chickpea Veggie Salad

    $6.45

  • Wreck Salad

    $6.45

Sides & Desserts

  • Chips

    $1.20

  • Side Salad

    $1.70

  • Sugar Cookie

    $1.25

  • Ice Cream Sandwich

    $2.80

  • Mini Choc Cookies

    $1.10

    2 Pack

  • Dream Bar

    $1.50

  • Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

    $1.25

  • Chocolate Brownie Cookie

    $1.25

  • Bag Mini Cookies

    $3.90

    12 Pc.

  • Pickle

    $1.00

Beverages

  • Soda

    $1.10

    Can

  • Arizona Tea

    $1.85

  • Nantucket Nectar

    $2.05

  • Crush

    $1.60

  • San Pellegrino

    $2.10

  • Izze Blackberry

    $1.90

  • Sobe Yum-Pom

    $2.10

  • Sobe Fuji Apple

    $2.10

  • Bottled Soda

    $1.85

    20 oz.

  • Bottled Water

    $2.10

    25 oz.

  • IBC

    $1.85

  • San Pellegrino Rosa

    $1.85

  • Izze Grapefruit

    $1.90

  • G2

    $2.00

Shakes

  • Classic Shake

    $2.90

  • Classic Smoothie

    $2.90

  • Fruit Shake

    $3.20

  • Fruit Smoothie

    $3.20

Box O'Sandwiches

  • Full Belly (Sandwich, Side Salad, Chips & Cookie)

    $9.35

    Each

  • Perfect Belly (Sandwich, Chips & Cookie)

    $7.65

    Each

  • Basic Belly ((Sandwich & Chips)

    $6.40

    Each

  • Just Sandwich (Only Sandwich)

    $5.20

    Each

Bowl O'Salads

  • Farmhouse Salad

    $39.00

    Group

  • Farmhouse Salad (No Chicken)

    $37.00

    Group

  • Uptown Salad

    $39.00

    Group

  • Uptown Salad (No Chicken)

    $37.00

    Group

Soup For A Group

  • Broccoli Cheddar

    $28.00

    Group

  • Chicken Enchilada

    $28.00

    Group

  • Lentil Kale & Turkey Sausage

    $28.00

    Group

  • Loaded Baked Potato

    $28.00

    Group

  • Garden Vegetable

    $28.00

    Group

  • Chicken Noodle

    $28.00

    Group

  • Tomato

    $28.00

    Group

  • Chili

    $34.00

    Group

Other Potbelly Sandwich Shop Locations in New York

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 100 Park Ave

100 Park Ave

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 101 Maiden Ln

101 Maiden Ln

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 127 Fulton St

127 Fulton St

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 150 E 44th St

150 E 44th St

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 150 E 52nd St

150 E 52nd St

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 19 W 45th St

19 W 45th St

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 22 E 17th St

22 E 17th St

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 280 Broadway

280 Broadway

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 30 Rockefeller Center

30 Rockefeller Center

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 333 7th Ave

333 7th Ave

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 333 Park Ave

333 Park Ave

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 333 Park Ave S

333 Park Ave S

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 366 5th Ave

366 5th Ave

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 41 W 14th St

41 W 14th St

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 46 W 56th St

46 W 56th St

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 501 7th Ave

501 7th Ave

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - 90 Broad St

90 Broad St

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Park Ave & E 40th St

Park Ave & E 40th St