Xtra's Cafe Menu and Prices

4.1 (120 reviews)37 menu items · 7 categoriesUpdated May 15, 2026

Xtra's Cafe is the kind of place you pass by and want to go in and get a cup of coffee. It has a name with "Xtra" and has no special shelf. Coffee is serious coffee, not to mess with the fancy ones. It is suitable for people who are in a hurry in the morning, or who want to find a place to sit for a while and be in a daze.

Starters

  • The Best Bruschetta

    $9.00

    Fresh tomatoes, capers, sweet basil, and fresh mozzarella served with grilled garlic oil pita points and a balsamic reduction

  • Low Country Shrimp Boil

    $9.00

    Jumbo shrimp slowly cooked in a southern spicy beer boil. Served with house cocktail sauce and fresh lemon.

  • Hummus Sampler

    $9.00

    Served with grilled garlic oil pita points and fresh seasonal vegetables

  • Xtra’s Fondue

    $7.00

    Creamy blue cheese fondue made with Stella Artois. Served hot with grilled garlic oil pita points, spiced honey, and Granny Smith apples

  • Ten Wings

    $9.00

    Choose up to two of our sauces: Sriracha-Buffalo, Bourbon Brown Sugar BBQ, and Five-Spice Dry Rub (Served with ranch or creamy gorgonzola)

  • Fried Veggie Rolls

    $7.00

    Grilled zucchini, yellow squash, carrots, corn, cabbage, and cilantro. Wrapped in egg roll wrappers and fried until golden. Served with spicy pineapple rum sauce

  • Artisan Cheese Plate

    $12.00

    Three cheeses; blue, soft, and hard, spiced honey, fruit jam, strawberries, pecans, grilled vegetables, and flat bread

Salads

  • Fresh Garden

    $4.00

    Mixed greens, carrots, cucumbers, herb roasted Romas, red onions, bell peppers, and croutons

  • Classic Grilled Caesar

    $4.00

    Grilled romaine hearts and parmesan, tossed with house Caesar dressing topped with Italian croutons and herb roasted Romas. (Dressing contains anchovies.)

  • Nantucket Nexus

    $6.00

    Mixed greens, cucumbers, red onions, cranberries, Granny Smith apples, Gorgonzola crumbles, and toasted pecans served with our balsamic vinaigrette on the side

  • Strawberry and Prosciutto

    $7.00

    Mixed greens, fresh strawberry, thinly sliced prosciutto, pecans, and Gouda served with our honey poppy vinaigrette on the side

Soups

  • Tomato Bisque

    $4.00

    Add grilled cheese $3.00

  • Soup Du Jour

    $0.00

    Add grilled cheese $3.00

Pita Pizzas

  • Smokehouse Chicken

    $10.00

    House made BBQ sauce, caramelized onion, grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar cheese, and mozzarella

  • Prosciutto and Gouda

    $10.00

    Roasted garlic oil, mozzarella, smoked gouda, prosciutto, caramelized onions, granny smith apples

  • The White Knight

    $8.00

    Roasted garlic cream, mozzarella, Parmesan, smoked gouda, fresh basil.

  • The Lady Liberty

    $8.00

    Create your own. Start with any sauce. Add mozzarella and Parmesan. Choose two toppings: Red onions, bell peppers, roasted red peppers, Granny Smith apples, tomatoes, mushrooms, basil.($0.50 for eac

Sandwiches

  • Xtra’s French Dip

    $9.00

    Hand-sliced tender beef, caramelized onions, and melted swiss, served on a toasted ciabatta roll, with au jus for dipping. (Lettuce and tomato upon request.)

  • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

    $10.00

    Your choice of grilled or fried chicken. Served with chopped lettuce, dice tomatoes sriracha-buffalo sauce, blue cheese, all wrapped in a flour tortilla

  • Crab Cake Sandwich

    $10.00

    Pan-fried crab cake served on a challah roll with lettuce tomato and drizzled with our Cajun Remoulade.

  • Bleu Cheese Stuffed Turkey Burger

    $9.00

    Lean turkey tossed with garlic, onions, and gorgonzola cheese, grilled to perfection. Served with lettuce, tomato, and charred red onion mayo

  • Black Angus Cheese Burger

    $10.00

    Eight ounces of fresh ground beef with your choice of cheese, served with lettuce, tomato, and charred red onion mayo. (add bacon or mushrooms for $1 extra.)

  • Panini Caprese

    $9.00

    Crispy grilled Italian bread, topped with tomatoes, fresh basil, grilled portabellas, and melted fresh mozzarella

  • Nantucket Turkey Melt

    $9.00

    Freshly roasted turkey, thin slices of granny smith apple, and melted sharp cheddar. Served on grilled sourdough with lettuce and tomato, and charred red onion mayo

Main Courses

  • Herb Tomato Poached Atlantic Salmon

    $18.00

    Herb tomatoes and fennel served with sautéed broccolini and cheddar infused grits

  • Xtra’s Crab Cakes

    $22.00

    Two large crabcakes, served with sautéed broccolini, black bean edamame succotash, fennel cucumber salsa and spicy cajun remoulade

  • Carytown Low Country Shrimp and Grits

    $17.00

    Jumbo gulf shrimp sautéed with chorizo sausage, scallions, roasted red pepper, and fresh basil in a sherry reduction cream sauce. Served with cheddar infused grits

  • Seasonal Vegetable Lasagna

    $15.00

    Thinly sliced seasonal vegetables layered with house made zesty marinara and mozzarella. Served with garlic bread and a side house or Caesar salad.

  • Stuffed Roasted Chicken

    $17.00

    Stuffed with gouda, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers, basil, prosciutto on a bed of pesto sauce. Served with seasonal vegetables and a fennel yukon potato au gratin topped with a balsamic

  • Petite Filet

    $24.00

    7oz Angus filet grilled to order. Served with a fennel Yukon potato au gratin, sautéed broccolini and finished in Stella Artois cheese fondue

  • Fish of the Day

    $0.00

    Your choice of grilled or sautéed. Served with fresh fennel cucumber salsa over black bean edamame succotash

  • Roasted Butternut Squash Medley

    $15.00

    Roasted with cranberries, pecans. Served over steamed rice with your choice of grilled tofu, shrimp, or chicken.

  • Create Your Own Pasta

    $10.00

    Choose any sauce:basil-pecan pesto, white wine butter garlic, zesty marinara, roasted garlic cream. Choose up to three toppings;Red onions, bell peppers, tomatoes, yellow squash, zucchini, caramelize

Homemade Desserts

  • Cheesecake

    $5.00
  • Bread Pudding A La Mode

    $5.00
  • Key Lime Pie

    $5.00
  • Dessert of the Day

    $0.00

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.