Sugar Sweet Sunshine Menu and Prices

4.8 (258 reviews)68 menu items · 8 categoriesUpdated June 8, 2026

The Cast of Cakes & Cupcakes

  • Sunshine

    $0.00

    Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream

  • Bob

    $0.00

    Yellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream

  • Ooey Gooey

    $0.00

    Chocolate cake with chocolate almond buttercream

  • Sexy Red Velvet

    $0.00

    Red velvet cake with the moose

  • Sassy Red Velvet

    $0.00

    Red Velvet cake with chocolate almond buttercream

  • Black & White

    $0.00

    Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream

  • Pistachio

    $0.00

    Pistachio cake with the moose

  • Lemon Yummy

    $0.00

    Lemon cake with lemon buttercream

  • Goodie Goodie

    $0.00

    Dark chocolate cake with whipped peanut butter buttercream

  • Faux-Coconut

    $0.00

    Coconut cake with satin buttercream

  • Strawberry

    $0.00

    Strawberry cake withcCream cheese or Peanut Butter buttercream

  • Holla Back Girl

    $0.00

    Banana cake with cream cheese icing

  • Oreo Cookie

    $0.00

    Oreo cupcake with satin buttercream

Layer Cakes

  • 7” Double Layer

    $30.00
  • 9” Double Layer

    $44.00
  • 7” Triple Layer

    $38.00
  • 9” Triple Layer

    $54.00
  • 10" Double Layer

    $65.00
  • 12” Double Layer

    $88.00
  • 9" x 12" Quarter Single Layer

    $54.00
  • 12” x 18” Single Layer Sheet Cake

    $88.00
  • 18" x 24" Full Sheet

    $185.00
  • 14" Double Layer

    $135.00
  • 16" Double Layer

    $185.00
  • 18" Double Layer

    $220.00

Icings

  • Vanilla Buttercream

    $0.00
  • Chocolate Almond Buttercream

    $0.00
  • Peanut Butter Buttercream

    $0.00
  • Mocha Buttercream

    $0.00
  • Satin Buttercream

    $0.00
  • Lemon Buttercream

    $0.00
  • Cream Cheese

    $0.00
  • Whipped Chocolate Buttercream

    $0.00

Decorations & Stuff

  • Basic Decoration

    $15.00
  • Inscriptions

    $3.00
  • Sprinkles

    $0.00

The Pudding Posse

  • Shot

    $3.00
  • 10 oz

    $5.00
  • 12 oz.

    $5.50
  • 16 oz.

    $7.00
  • 64 oz. Tub

    $35.00

Not Layer Cakes

  • Angel Food

    $35.00
  • Pistachio Bundt

    $35.00
  • Marble Bundt

    $35.00
  • Lemon Bundt

    $35.00
  • Inescapeable Apple Cake

    $35.00
  • The Real Deal Coffee Cake

    $35.00
  • Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

    $35.00
  • I Love New York Cheesecake

    $45.00
  • Mini Cheesecakes

    $2.50
  • Plain

    $2.50
  • Fancy Schmansey (Fruit Combo)

    $2.50
  • Chocolate Chippies

    $2.50

Pies

  • Apple

    $25.00
  • Coconut Cream

    $25.00
  • Strawberry Rhubarb

    $25.00
  • Peanut Butter Ice Box

    $25.00
  • Pecan

    $25.00
  • Pumpkin

    $25.00
  • Blueberry Crispy Crumble

    $25.00

Sugar Sweet Specialties

  • 7” Double Layer Strawberry shortcake

    $40.00
  • 9” Double Layer Strawberry shortcake

    $54.00
  • Brownies

    $3.25
  • Yum-Yum Bars

    $3.25
  • Lemon Bars

    $3.25
  • Cookies

    $0.75

    Chocolate chip, mint chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, sugar, red velvet and more

  • Cookies Baker Dozen

    $9.00

    Chocolate chip, mint chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, sugar, red velvet and more

  • Iced Sugar Cookies

    $1.50

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.