Proto's Pizza Menu and Prices

4.8 (418 reviews)67 menu items · 10 categoriesUpdated June 5, 2026

Appetizers & Fresh Salads

  • Savory Pannini

    $3.75

    a steamy hot pillow of baked dough topped with crushed red pepper, oregano & parmesan cheese, served with olive oil and balsamic vinegar

  • Caesar Salad

    $5.99

    crispy romaine tossed with our caesar dressing, pecorino romano, white anchovies and house made crouton

  • Tomato & Mozzarella Salad

    $5.99

    sliced red tomatoes mingled with fresh mozzarella and basil, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil, balsamic vinegar reduction and kosher salt

  • Mixed Organic Greens

    $4.99

    with proto’s own balsamic vinaigrette

  • Capri Salad

    $5.99

    romaine, sliced ham, hearts of palm, and corn, tossed in extra virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar

  • Tuscan Salad

    $5.99

    romaine, Mediterranean tuna, capers, red onion and tomatoes, tossed in extra virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar

  • Add Mediterranean tuna or Haystack Mountain Feta to any salad

    $1.50

Napoletana Style Pizza

  • The Traditional

    $5.99

    mozzarella and proto’s homemade tomato sauce

  • Pizza Margherita

    $7.99

    san marzano tomatoes, mozzarella and fresh basil

  • The Annie

    $6.99

    mozzarella, tomato sauce, sliced tomatoes and oregano

  • The Atomica Pie

    $8.99

    mozzarella, tomato sauce, garlic, oregano, then sprinkled with crushed red pepper, black olives, and topped with italian sausage

  • The AP

    $6.99

    mozzarella, tomato sauce, anchovies and oregano

  • The Ruby Pie

    $8.99

    pesto, mozzarella, haystack mountain feta cheese, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts

  • Pontiff Pie

    $8.99

    olive oil, garlic, fresh spinach, sundried tomatoes, mozzarella and haystack

  • The Roman

    $8.99

    mozzarella, tomato sauce, kalamata olives, capers and roasted red peppers

  • The Proto Pie

    $7.99

    mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh basil and italian sausage

  • Pesto Pie

    $6.99

    mozzarella and fresh pesto

  • White Pie

    $5.99

    garlic infused olive oil, mozzarella and oregano

  • The Goombah

    $8.99

    tomato sauce, mozzarella, capers, and imported prosciutto

  • Hula Pie

    $7.99

    mozzarella, tomato sauce, sliced ham, and fresh pineapple

  • Margherita D.O.C.G

    $13.99

    san marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil

  • Traffic Jam

    $15.99

    a big mess of toppings...tomato sauce, sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, mushrooms, green peppers, onions and our whole milk mozzarella

  • Low Rider

    $8.99

    blend of house made honey tomato chipotle sauce, topped with mozzarella, polidori bacon, fresh pineapple and cilantro

  • Tomato Pie

    $7.99

    proto’s own red sauce, topped with fresh tomatoes, crushed san marzano tomatoes, kosher salt and oregano

  • Add fresh toppings to create your own pizza

    $0.00

    white mushrooms, green peppers, basil, roasted red peppers, garlic, sun dried tomatoes, black olives, ham, fresh pineapple, tomatoes, meatballs, red jalapenos, italian sausage, fresh spinach, articho

  • Extra toppings

    $1.00
  • For Extra Cheese

    $2.00

    margherita tomatoes, prosciutto or pesto

  • Friday Night Is Clam Pizza

    $0.00

    night from 4pm til’ we run out. eat clam pizza at least once in your life and you will be hooked!

Liquid Therapy

  • The Classic Martini

    $6.50

    gin or vodka? twist or olives? straight up or on the rocks? the choice is yours.

  • The Cosmopolitan

    $7.50

    our new standard. absolut citron, cointreau, cranberry juice, fresh lime and icy lovin’.

  • Proto’s Marg

    $8.50

    resistance got us nowhere, so here it is! Up or on the rocks with corzo tequila, lots of fresh lime and a splash of cointreau.

  • Lemon Drop

    $7.50

    we kick the neighbor’s kid’s lemonade stand in the ass with our icy cool twist on the porch swing beverage.

  • The Premium Classic

    $7.50

    bombay sapphire gin, absolut citron, absolut peppar or belvedere vodka? shaken or stirred? up or on the rocks? served arctic.

  • The Prototini

    $7.50

    chilled absolut vanilia, italian espresso beans, a dash of coffee liquor, some cream and a hint of sugar.

  • The Sicilian Martini

    $7.00

    absolut peppar vodka, a dash of bloody mary mix, a kick of spice, garnished with anchovy stuffed olives.

  • Proto’s Bloody

    $7.00

    house infused hot peppar vodka and bloody mary mix. great on a sunday at lunch or any other time really

  • Sangria

    $7.00

    proudly served at all rossello family gatherings. choose white or red.

Wine By The Glass - White

  • Wine By The Glas - White

    $6.50

    cusumano inzolia, sicily, italy

Desserts

  • Traditional Italian Cannolis

    $5.00

    thick flaky pastry flute with a sweet ricotta filling

  • Spruce Confections New York Cheese Cake

    $5.00

    creamy, rich and good

  • Italian Tartuffo

    $5.00

    chocolate and vanilla gelato rolled in fine cocoa powder and hazelnuts

  • Limoncello Tartuffo

    $5.00

    lemon gelato with a sweet lemon syrup center rolled in powdered lemon sugar

  • Gelato d'Italia

    $5.00

    assorted yummy flavors

  • Affogato al Caffe

    $6.00

    a single shot of espresso poured over your favorite gelato

  • Tiramisu

    $6.00

    we make it and you will love it

  • Black or White Sambucca

    $6.00

    snifter

Wine By The Glass- white

  • Wine by the glass - White

    $8.25

    herding cats chenin blanc/ chardonnay, south africa

Wine by the Glass - Red

  • Wine by the Glass-Red

    $6.50

    rex goliath pinot noir, monterey county, ca

  • Wine by the Glass- Red

    $5.75

    oak grove petit sirah, ca

Beers

  • On Tap

    $0.00

    check handles - ask servers (they love to chat) 12 oz/pint/pitcher

  • Not on Tap

    $4.00

    boddington cans, guiness, stella artois

Beverages

  • Sodas

    $1.50

    coke, sprite, fresca, diet coke, mr. pibb, barq’s root beer

  • Italian Sodas

    $1.75

    ask server for flavors

  • Izze Sodas

    $2.50
  • Amante Coffee

    $1.60
  • Amante Espresso

    $2.00
  • Amante Cappuccino

    $3.00
  • Extra Shot of Espresso

    $1.00
  • San Pellegrino & Panna

    $3.00
  • Lemonade & Pekoe Iced Tea

    $1.75
  • Ice Cold Milk

    $1.50
  • Chocolate Milk

    $1.75
  • Pekoe Tea

    $1.75

    ask server for selection

Protos Gift Items

  • T-shirts

    $15.00
  • Long Sleeve

    $24.00
  • Ladies T’s

    $20.00
  • Ball Caps

    $16.00

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.