P.J. Clarke's Menu and Prices

4.4 (335 reviews)64 menu items · 13 categoriesUpdated June 26, 2026

Shares

  • Crisp Parmesan Tater Tots

    $11.10

    Spiced tomato ketchup

  • Zucchini Chips & Crispy Feta

    $12.15

    Tzatziki dip

  • Yeloowfin Tuna Tartare Tacos

    $14.25

    Avocado, lime crema

  • Crisp Point Judith Calamari

    $14.65

    Traditional or rhode island style

  • Parmesan Crusted Eggplant Sticks

    $9.85

    Raw tomato dipping sauce

  • Cast Iron Baked Macaroni & Cheese

    $14.55

    Bacon lardons, green onions

Salads

  • Chopped Kale & Avocado Salad

    $10.25

    Feta, sweet & spicy walnuts, lemonette dressing

  • Iceberg Wedge

    $10.15

    Bacon, tomato, buttermilk bleu cheese

  • Classic Caesar

    $10.65

    Kitchen croutons

Entree Salads

  • Grilled Hudson Volley Chicken

    $19.65
  • Maryland Lump Crab Cake

    $28.25
  • Sliced Angus Skirt Steak

    $25.25
  • Skuna Bay Salmon

    $24.25
  • 3rd Ave. Jumbo Shrimp Chopped Salad

    $22.85

Soups

  • French Onion Gratinee

    $9.45
  • New England Clam Chowder

    $10.80
  • Creamy Tomato Soup

    $9.55

    Farmstead cheddar toast

Sefood

  • Tottenham Fish & Chips

    $22.90

    Chunky tartar sauce, malt vinegar

  • Montauk Fish Tacos

    $20.65

    Avocado lime crema, crunchy baked yuca logs

  • Black Pot PEI Mussels Frites

    $19.65

    French sailor style: Shallots, white wine, garlic & thyme provencal: Smoked tomato with herbs

Sandwiches

  • Stacked Corned Beef Reuben

    $18.25

    Homemade kraut & swiss, chips, pickle

  • Bel-Air Country Club

    $17.55

    Nautural roast turkey, bacon, gruyere, fried egg, avocado, mayonnaise

  • Buffalo Chickne Breast

    $18.60

    Melted local blue cheese, lettuce, pickled carrots, chips

  • Maryland Jumbo Lump Crab Cake

    $20.25

    Chunky tartar sauce, old bay chips

Classics

  • Free Range Chicken Pot Pie

    $21.80

    Hudson valley farmed chicken, green market root vegetables

  • King George's Shepherd's Pie

    $18.75
  • Farmer's Crunchy Chicken Breast

    $19.55

    Sesame-honey soy sauce, zucchini wafers

  • Crispy Sweet & Spicy Duck Leg Confit

    $19.55

    Apricot & honey glaze, crunchy rice

  • Grilled Chicken Paillard

    $22.85

    Arugula, fennel, red onion, shaved baked ricotta, lemonette dressing

  • Dry Aged Skirt Steak Frites (12oz.)

    $29.90

    Choice of sauce bearnaise, classique, roquefort or neat

Hamburgers

  • The Clarke Burger

    $12.50

    Roma tomatoes, cheese, lettuce, bread & butter pickles

  • Hamburger Au Poivre

    $14.50

    Cracked pepper sauce, cabot cheddar, jimmy peppers & onions

  • The Cadillac

    $14.85

    Double smoked country bacon, american cheese

  • BBQ Bleu Burger

    $13.85

    Crispy shallots, buttermilk bleu cheese, BBQ sauce

  • Wild Mushroom Cheddar Burger

    $15.20

    Wild mushrooms, whiskey onion sauce, cabot cheddar

  • Kimchi Burger

    $14.05

    Cabbage slaw, fried egg, sesame scallion mayonnaise

  • Trio of Mini Burgers

    $14.65

    Cheeseburger, the cadillac, wild mushroom cheddar burger

  • Organic Turkey Burger

    $18.85

    Pickled tomato jam, sweet potato fries

Raw

  • East & West Coast Oysters

    $0.00
  • Long Island Littleneck Clams

    $0.00

    1/2 Dozen or dozen

  • Long Island Cherrystone Clams

    $0.00

    1/2 Dozen or dozen

  • Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

    $19.25
  • Baker's Dozen Oyster Sampler

    $36.25

Lobster Roll

  • Tokyo

    $0.00

    A light but spicy version made with yuzu a japanese citrus, kewpie mayonnaise and red chili flakes

  • Wiscasset, Maine

    $0.00

    Classic new england with just a touch of mayonnaise

  • Naked

    $0.00

    Warm chunks of lobster, with drawn butter on the side

Sides

  • Onion Strings

    $6.85
  • Yukon Gold Hash Browns

    $6.15

    Rosemary, fennel & shallots

  • Hand Cut Sweet Potato Fries

    $6.55
  • Creamed or Sauteed Spinach

    $6.85
  • Shoestring Fries

    $6.20
  • Baked Sweet Potato

    $6.35

    Creme fraiche & chives

  • Mashed Potatoes

    $5.90

    With beef dripping

  • Jumbo Grilled Asparagus

    $8.35
  • Shaved Brussels Sprouts

    $7.25

    Double smoked bacon

Desserts

  • Whiskey Bread Pudding

    $8.85

    Eat responsibly

  • New York Cheesecake

    $10.25

    Blueberry compote

  • Apple & Rhubarb Cobbler

    $9.05
  • 1955 Butterscotch Pudding

    $7.75
  • Chocolate Fudge Brownie Sundae

    $9.45

English Standard Iced Tea

  • Balck Rose

    $4.00
  • Red Mango

    $4.00
  • Honeysuckle Mint

    $4.00
  • Green Honey

    $4.00

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.