Omarl's Menu and Prices

4.2 (441 reviews)19 menu items · 4 categoriesUpdated July 7, 2026

A friend who goes to dinner often mentioned this Omarl's and said it was the kind of store where no mistakes could be made. After going there, I found that it was true-the menu was simple and nothing fancy, but everything was done quite seriously. It is suitable to come alone after work, or grab friends and go directly when you are too lazy to eat.

Appetizers

  • Mozzarella Caprese

    $7.95

    fresh house made mozzarella with beef steak, tomatoes, fresh basil, roasted rot peppers, kalamata olives and capers served with toasted crostini

  • Jamaican Beef Wellington

    $7.95

    served with mango sauce

  • Smith Island Crab Cakes

    $8.95

    served with roasted red pepper cream sauce

  • Warm Lobster Dip

    $6.95

    served with toasted crostini

  • Shrimp Scampi

    $7.95

    sauteed shrimp served over mayport grits with provolone sauce

Soup

  • Soup Du Jour

    $2.95
  • Seafood Chowder

    $3.95

Salad

  • Jerk Chicken Caesar

    $7.95

    marinated chicken over a bed of greens

  • Omaris' House Salad

    $3.95

Entrees

  • Caribbean Pork Loin

    $14.95

    served with sweet potato plantain mashed with roasted red pepper cream sauce

  • Filet of Snapper

    $17.95

    broiled and topped with tropical fruit salsa

  • Chicken Artichoke French

    $14.95

    topped with artichokes and mushrooms and finished with sherry

  • Apple Smoked Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops

    $18.95

    served over capellini with a dijon white wine cream sauce

  • Roasted Half Duck

    $16.95

    with a tangerine demi glaze plantain sweet potato mashed potato

  • Salmon Tiki

    $16.95

    grilled with a plum sauce glaze and topped with fried spinach

  • Steak Diane

    $21.95

    NY strip steak topped with wild mushroom cabernet demi glaze

  • Beef Tenderloin and Stuffed Shrimp

    $24.95

    tomatoes of beef topped with crabmeat stuffed shrimp finished with bernaise sauce

  • Prime Rib of Beef

    $12.95

    served with an jus

  • Jamacian Jerk Chicken

    $12.95

    jerk marinated half chicken

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.