Old Hickery Steakhouse Menu and Prices

4.3 (329 reviews)34 menu items · 4 categoriesUpdated June 14, 2026

Old Hickery Steakhouse is a typical American steakhouse that specializes in thick-cut steaks, grilled on charcoal, and tender on the outside. The menu is simple and crude, mainly consisting of various steak parts-rib-eye, filet, New Yorker, served with a baked potato or creamed spinach. The environment is dark, with wooden tables and chairs, suitable for friends to have dinner together or when they want to eat big chunks of meat. If you want to find a place to eat steak seriously, order it medium or medium rare, paired with a glass of red wine. It is a non-trivial choice.

Starters

  • Key West Calamari Strips

    $11.00

    island orchard orange and horseradish aioli

  • Ahi Tuna Three Ways

    $13.00

    tuna tartar and ginger soy dressing, seared tuna and udon noodle salad, tuna carpaccio

  • Caribbean Pulled Pork

    $9.00

    polenta cake, mango and port essence

  • Jumbo Lump Crab Cake

    $13.00

    dressed watercress, cilantro, bartlett pear, spicy remoulade

  • Crab and Spinach Dip

    $10.00

    artichokes, hearts of palm, key west krackers

  • Prince Edward Island Mussels

    $10.00

    fragrant curried coconut lime broth, grilled garlic sourdough

  • Conch Fritters

    $10.00

    scotch bonnet pepper remoulade sauce

  • Raw Bar Platter

    $18.00

    four blue point oysters, four middleneck clams, three ounces sweet gulf shrimp ceviche, four tiger shrimp, served with jerk cocktail and key lime mignonette sauce

  • Three Tiered Tower

    $31.00

    sam says, 'friends that eat gotether, stay together'. conch fritters, cigar shrimp, lobster skewers, grilled pineapple, blue crab salad, ahi tuna tartar, shrimp cocktail, and udon noodles served with

Soups and Salads

  • Clam and Conch Chowder

    $7.00
  • Spring Mix of Greens

    $8.00

    sliced cucumbers, grape tomatoes, aged balsamic dressing, saga bleu cheese

  • Butter Poached Sweet Lobster Salad

    $14.00

    watercress, blood orange, bosc pear, strawberry vinaigrette

  • Crab Bisque

    $7.00
  • Balsamic Grilled Portobello

    $9.00

    baby spinach, queso fresco, applewood smoked bacon dressing

  • Heart of romaine Caesar Salad

    $8.00

    garlic croutons, crispy parmesan

Dayboat Selections

  • Grilled Swordfish

    $26.00
  • Blackened Escolar

    $26.00
  • Pan roasted Black Grouper

    $26.00
  • Seared Ahi Tuna

    $26.00
  • Sauteed Tilefish

    $26.00
  • Broiled Mako Shark

    $26.00
  • Grilled Mahi Mahi

    $26.00
  • Bronzed Cobia

    $26.00
  • Lemongrass Salmon

    $26.00

Main Plates

  • Crispy Whole Yellowtail Snapper

    $29.00

    buttery white rice and red beans, sauteed vegetables, citrus soy

  • Seared George's Bank Sea Scallops

    $25.00

    rock shrimp and corn risotto, navel butter, petit greens

  • Grilled Pork Tenderloin

    $21.00

    coffee-scented barbecue sauce, boniato gratin potato, sauteed autumn vegetables, crispy onions

  • Certified Angus NY Strip

    $32.00

    sauteed autumn vegetables, roasted marble mix potatoes, chimichurri and tomatillo salsa

  • Grilled Florida Mahi Mahi

    $24.00

    cracked conch and tomato stew, cheese polenta cakes, basil aioli

  • Lemongrass Glazed Grilled Salmon

    $25.00

    spinach, shiitake mushroom, roasted fingerling potato, polenta crouton, tupelo honey vinaigrette, red onion jam

  • Tempura Battered Rare Tuna 'Lollipops'

    $26.00

    udon noodles, ponzu, wasabi drizzle

  • Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes

    $26.00

    fingerling potato and sauted corn, warm applewood bacon dressing, sweet corn nectar

  • Fisherman's Stew

    $29.00

    tiger shrimp, rock lobster, cracked conch, middlenech clams, prince edward island mussels, fresh fish, vine ripe tomato, saffron scented broth

  • Seafood and Papardelle Pasta

    $29.00

    sauteed shrimp, scallops, floridian rock lobster, parmesan and roasted garlic cream

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.