Nick & Toni's Cafe Menu and Prices

4.2 (261 reviews)32 menu items · 8 categoriesUpdated June 13, 2026

Nick & Toni's Cafe sounds like a small cafe, but the menu is actually quite mixed-American snacks, pasta, and pizza. Of course, there is coffee, which is suitable for people who want to eat something that is not complicated. The atmosphere is more casual than a serious Italian restaurant, and more pyrotechnic than a fast food restaurant. It's easy to order a pizza with a cup of coffee. It's easy to eat it yourself or have a meal with friends.

Insalate

  • Stokes Farm Cavolo Nero Crudo

    $15.00

    roasted butternut squash, house-made pancetta and grana padano.

  • Migliorelli Farm Arugula Salad

    $14.00

    roasted beets, goat cheese and red wine vinaigrette. vegetarian.

  • Greenmarket Baby Spinach Salad

    $16.00

    chanterelle mushrooms and toasted hazelnuts. vegetarian.

  • Romaine Salad

    $14.00

    caesar dressing, garlic croutons and grana padano.

Antipasti

  • Crispy Chicken Livers

    $15.00

    frisee and balsamic onions.

Primi

  • Penne Alla Vecchia Bettola

    $15.00

    spicy oven-roasted tomato sauce. vegetarian.

  • Cheese Pumpkin Tortelloni

    $18.00

    brown butter, sage and toasted hazelnuts.

Sandwiches

  • Pollo Panini

    $15.00

    grilled chicken breast, roasted red peppers, arugula, lemon aioli and rustic italian bread.

  • Fried Green Tomato Blt Panini

    $14.00

    stokes farm lettuces, crispy bacon, spicy mayo and focaccia.

  • Turkey Burger

    $15.00

    lettuce, tomato, pickles, french fries and your choice of extras. cheese: fontina, mozzarella, gorgonzola or bobolink cheddar cheese.

  • Sawmill Brook Farm Grass-Fed Black Angus Hamburger

    $18.00

    served with lettuce, tomato, horman's pickles and french fries with your choice of cheese: fontina, mozzarella, gorgonzola or bobolink cheddar cheese.

  • Burger: Additions

    $1.00

    wild mushrooms, sauteed onion or pancetta.

Secondi

  • Knoll Crest Farm Egg Frittata

    $14.00

    local greens and roasted tomato.

  • Grilled Arctic Char

    $17.00

    greenmarket cranberry beans and mixed peppers.

  • Roast Chicken Salad

    $17.00

    local arugula, cucumber, chickpeas and lemon vinaigrette.

  • Oven-Roasted Natural Chicken

    $18.00

    berried treasures yukon gold potatoes, pancetta, garlic and rosemary jus.

  • Grilled Prime Hanger Steak Salad

    $18.00

    greenmarket arugula and chopped vegetable salad with caper aioli.

Contorni

  • Lunch Crushed Greenmarket Yukon Gold Potatoes

    $8.00
  • Greenmarket Greens

    $10.00
  • Lunch Eggplant Caponata

    $9.00
  • Hand-Cut French Fries

    $6.00

Pizza Al Forno

  • Margherita Pizza

    $15.00

    housemade mozzarella, tomato sauce and fresh basil. vegetarian.

  • Uovo Pizza

    $16.00

    local potato, bacon, grana padano, knoll crest egg, truffle oil.

  • Zucca Pizza

    $17.00

    roasted butternut squash, house-made pancetta, shallots, pecorino romano.

  • Salsiccia Pizza

    $17.00

    housemade sweet sausage, north fork mushrooms and provolone picante.

Desserts

  • Gingerbread

    $11.00

    ginger cream, molasses pine nuts, and halsey farms pear-riesling sorbetto.

  • Caramel Apple Hand Pie

    $12.00

    candied pecans, streusel, cinnamon gelato.

  • Napoleon

    $12.00

    white chocolate mousse, praline cream, hazelnut sponge, brittle.

  • Tartufo

    $13.00

    caramel truffle, chocolate and hazelnut gelato, almond biscotti crumbs.

  • Nick And Toni's Biscotti

    $9.00
  • Halsey Farms Pumpkin Trifle

    $11.00

    pumpkin cremeux, spiced chocolate cake, cocoa nibs, bourbon

  • Profiteroles

    $12.00

    roasted banana gelato, malted peanuts and butterscotch sauce.

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.