New York Pizza Suprema Menu and Prices

4.6 (190 reviews)41 menu items · 6 categoriesUpdated June 3, 2026

Calzones & Rolls $6

  • Calzone

    $0.00

    imported romano and the finest ricotta and grande mozzarella cheeses.

  • Sausage Roll

    $0.00

    sausage, onions, peppers, imported romano and the finest mozzarella cheese. no sauce.

  • Meat Parmigiana Roll

    $0.00

    onion-based sauce, meatballs, imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheeses.

  • Chicken Parmigiana Roll

    $0.00

    onion-based sauce, lightly breaded perdue white meat chicken cutlet, imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheeses. no sauce.

  • Eggplant Parmigiana Roll

    $0.00

    onion-based sauce, lightly breaded eggplant, imported romano, the finest ricotta and grande mozzarella cheeses.

  • Broccoli Roll

    $0.00

    broccoli and light garlic with the finest ricotta and grande mozzarella cheese.

  • Spinach Roll

    $0.00

    spinach and light garlic with the finest ricotta and grande mozzarella cheeses.

Signature Pizza Pies

  • Round Cheese Pizza

    $20.00

    light, thin crust topped with house tomato sauce, the finest grande mozzarella and romano cheeses.

  • Fresh Mozzarella With Basil Pizza

    $25.00

    house-made fresh mozzarella. the crust is topped with a plum tomato sauce, the fresh mozzarella placed in between, sprinkled with a generous layer of imported romano cheese, then topped off with a sw

  • White Pizza

    $25.00

    oozing with imported romano and the finest ricotta and grande mozzarella cheeses. no sauce.

  • Sicilian Pizza

    $25.00

    new york-style sicilian pizza cooked with an onion-based sauce, sprinkled with imported italian romano cheese, covered with the finest grande mozzarella on a light and airy deep dish square crust.

  • Upside Down Pizza

    $25.00

    a sauce lover`s favorite. the finest grande mozzarella covers a light and airy deep dish square crust. the mozzarella covered with an onion-based sauce, then finished with imported romano cheese and

  • Grandma Pizza

    $27.00

    thin crust, sicilian-style pizza with fresh mozzarella, fresh tomato, freshly crushed garlic and imported pecorino romano cheese.

  • Marinara Pizza

    $20.00

    a garlic-based marinara sauce, sprinkled with imported romano cheese and finished with fresh basil. no mozzarella.

Specialty Pizza Pies

  • Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

    $25.00

    topped with lightly breaded perdue white meat chicken cutlet, imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheese.

  • Chicken Parmigiana & Tomato Pizza

    $27.00

    chicken parmesan pizza topped with diced fresh tomatoes.

  • Supreme Special Pizza

    $27.00

    topped with sausage, pepperoni, onion, peppers and fresh mushrooms.

  • Chicken & Broccoli Pizza

    $27.00

    topped with lightly breaded perdue white meat chicken cutlet and broccoli.

  • Veggie Lover's Pizza

    $27.00

    topped with spinach, broccoli, onions, peppers and fresh mushrooms.

  • Meat Lover's Pizza

    $27.00

    topped with ham, sausage, pepperoni and meatballs.

  • Cheese Lover's Pizza

    $27.00

    with combination of the finest cheeses, including grande mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, ricotta and romano cheeses.

  • White Eggplant Pizza

    $27.00

    white pie topped with lightly breaded eggplant cutlets. no sauce.

  • Hawaiian Pizza

    $25.00

    topped with ham and pineapple.

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    $25.00

    topped with buffalo chicken.

Stuffed Pizza Pies $40

  • Roman Pizza

    $0.00

    ham, sausage and pepperoni with imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheeses surrounded by a thin light golden crust all around. no sauce.

  • Lasagna Pizza

    $0.00

    12 slices. sausage, meatball, ricotta, imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheeses surrounded by a thin light golden crust all round.

  • Stuffed Vegetable Pizza

    $0.00

    12 slices. fresh mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheeses surrounded by a thin light crust all round.

Pizza Slices

  • Round Cheese Pizza Slice

    $3.00

    light thin crust topped with house tomato sauce, the finest grande mozzarella and romano cheeses.

  • Fresh Mozzarella With Basil Pizza Slice

    $3.75

    house-made fresh mozzarella. the crust is topped with a plum tomato sauce, the fresh mozzarella placed in between, sprinkled with a generous layer of imported romano cheese, then topped off with a sw

  • White Pizza Slice

    $3.75

    oozing with imported romano and the finest ricotta and grande mozzarella cheeses. no sauce.

  • Sicilian Pizza Slice

    $3.00

    new york-style sicilian pizza cooked in an onion-based sauce, sprinkled with imported italian romano cheese, covered with the finest grande mozzarella on a light and airy deep dish square crust.

  • Upside Down Pizza Slice

    $3.00

    a sauce lover`s favorite. the finest grande mozzarella covers a light and airy deep dish square crust. the mozzarella covered with an onion-based sauce, then finished with imported romano cheese and

  • Grandma Pizza Slice

    $3.75

    thin crust, sicilian-style fresh mozzarella, fresh tomato, freshly crushed garlic and imported pecorino romano cheese.

  • Marinara Pizza Slice

    $2.50

    a garlic-based marinara sauce, sprinkled with imported romano cheese and finished with fresh basil. no mozzarella.

  • Chicken Parmigiana Pizza Slice

    $3.75

    topped with lightly breaded perdue white meat chicken cutlet, imported romano and the finest grande mozzarella cheese.

  • Chicken Parmigiana & Tomato Pizza Slice

    $4.25

    chicken parmesan pizza topped with diced fresh tomatoes.

  • Supreme Special Pizza Slice

    $4.25

    topped with sausage, pepperoni, onion, peppers and fresh mushrooms.

  • Chicken & Broccoli Pizza Slice

    $4.25

    topped with lightly breaded perdue white meat chicken cutlet and broccoli.

  • Hawaiian Pizza Slice

    $3.75

    topped with ham and pineapple.

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice

    $3.75

    topped with buffalo chicken.

Beverages

  • 2-Liter Bottle Of Soda

    $4.00

    coke, diet coke, sprite, ginger ale, orange soda.

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.