Naegelin's Bakery Menu and Prices

4.2 (491 reviews)15 menu items · 4 categoriesUpdated May 10, 2026

Strudel

  • Apple Strudel

    $18.75

    2 feet in length and weights approx. 4 1/2 pounds, with a delightful blend of apples and a touch of cinnamon, coconut, and cherries to give you a unique taste in a finely rolled puff pastry dough.

  • Carmel Apple Strudel

    $19.75

    2 feet in length and weights approx. 4 1/2 pounds, with a delightful blend of apples and carmel with just the right amount of cinnamon to give you a unique taste in a finely rolled puff pastry dough.

  • Cherry Strudel

    $22.75

    The strudel's cherry filling combined with a finely rolled puff pastry dough is quite a delight

  • Peach Strudel

    $19.75

    Our peach strudel is loaded with luscious peaches in a finely rolled puff pastry dough.

Pastries

  • Bear Claws (DOZ)

    $10.95

    A Dozen Bearclaws made with brown sugar, cinnamon and pecans, along with our own unique danish dough that is folded 12 times during preparation makes for a scrumptious pastry.

  • Sweet German Pretzels (4)

    $10.00

    A tender puff pastry dough with a brown sugar, butter and pecan filling!

10" Pies

  • German Chocolate 10" Pie

    $24.95

    This is a rich creamy pie with the right amount of pecans and coconut

  • Pecan Pie 10"

    $26.95

    Served with this classic southern pecan pie.

Cookies

  • German Cookie Assortment

    $9.50

    A great assortment of german cookies including a 1/2 dozen of Iced molasses cookies, a 1/2 dozen of lebkuchen cookies, a 1/2 dozen of pfefernuesse cookies, and a 1/2 dozen of spingerle cookies.

  • Gingerbread Men (4 Count)

    $8.00
  • Iced Molasses (1 doz)

    $5.75

    A dozen sweet slow molasses cookies covered with icing.

  • Lebkuchen (1 doz)

    $5.75

    Made with brown sugar, honey, cinnamon and a hint of anise.

  • Pfefernuesse (1 doz.)

    $5.25

    A spicy cookie with cinnamon, pecans and a hint of anise. Rolled in powdered sugar

  • Smiley Face Cookies (1 doz)

    $5.75
  • Spingerle (1 doz.)

    $5.25

    A crunchy cookie with a heavy anise flavor.

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.