Montego Bay Menu and Prices

4.2 (235 reviews)32 menu items · 5 categoriesUpdated May 11, 2026

Island Appetizers

  • Key West Wings

    $8.95

    tender chicken deep-fried and tossed in a sweet and spicy wings sauce, served with ranch for dipping and a side of crisp celery sticks.

  • Crab & Artichoke Dip

    $9.95

    a delectable mixture of crab, bay shrimp, artichoke hearts, mixed cheese and spices, served with pita chips.

  • Kona Quesadilla

    $6.95

    a delicious blend of four cheeses in a crispy grilled tortilla, served with a side of sour cream and salsa. add chicken or bay shrimp $2.00.

  • Jalapeno Poppers

    $6.95

    cream cheese filled peppers, lightly breaded and cooked to a golden brown, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

  • Cancun Calamari

    $9.95

    freshly sliced, lightly breaded and fried to a golden perfection, served with a zesty marinara for dipping.

  • Gator Eggs

    $5.95

    tender mini turkey corn dogs served golden brown with a side of our creamy mustard sauce for dipping.

  • Mazatlan Cheese Sticks

    $6.95

    mozzarella cheese lightly breaded and cooked to perfection served with a side of zesty marinara sauce.

  • Potato Skins

    $7.50

    crispy potato skins topped with melting cheese, sour cream, scallions and crumbled bacon. yummy!

  • Montego Platter

    $15.95

    a bounty of gator eggs, jalapeno poppers, key west wings, onion rings, and mazatlan cheese sticks with your choice of dipping sauces to excite your taste buds!

  • Nassau Nachos

    $8.95

    tri-colored tortilla chips topped with a melting cheese blend, sliced olives, green onions, fresh tomatoes, jalapenos, and chili served with a side of sour cream and salsa. add chicken $2.00.

  • Sauteed Mushrooms

    $7.50

    button mushrooms sauteed in butter, garlic, and white wine cream sauce then topped with melting parmesan cheese, with a side of pita chips.

  • Captians Coconut Prawns

    $7.95

    3 tender jumbo prawns tossed in a light breading mixed with sweet toasted coconut flakes, presented with a sweet and spicy marmalade sauce.

Island Salads

  • House Salad

    $5.95

    mixed cheese, fresh tomatoes, olives, mushrooms, and red onion served on a bed of mixed greens and your choice of dressing.

  • Caesar Salad

    $6.95

    crisp romaine lettuce tossed in our special caesar dressing topped with fresh grated parmesan cheese, seasoned croutons, a tomato wedge and lemon.

Island Burgers & Sandwiches

  • Classic Cheeseburger

    $7.95

    1/2 pound of juicy ground steak grilled to your liking and served with your choice of cheese.

  • Montego Bacon Cheese Burger

    $7.50

    delicious ground steak topped with hickory smokey bacon and your choice of melting cheese.

  • Shroom 'N' Swiss Burger

    $8.50

    a flavorful ground steak patty with melting swiss cheese and topped with tender sauteed mushrooms.

  • Hawaiian Burger

    $8.95

    a mouth-watering ground steak patty that is marinated in our home made teriyaki sauce, grilled to your satisfaction and topped with a grilled pineapple ring and melting swiss cheese. oh yeah!

  • Shroom 'N' Swiss Chicken Burger

    $7.50

    our naked grilled chicken breast topped with melting swiss cheese and sauteed mushrooms and onions.

  • Prime Rib Philly Sandwich

    $8.95

    mouth-watering prime rib thinly sliced and topped with tender sauteed mushrooms, peppers, onions, and melting swiss cheese on a hoagie roll with a side of homemade au jus for dipping.

  • Classic French Dip

    $7.95

    juicy prime rib thinly sliced and served on a hoagie roll with a side of homemade au jus for dipping.

Island Finger Foods

  • Tiki Fish & Chips

    $9.95

    lightly dusted pieces of fresh halibut, tender moist, and full of flavor, served with our ever-popular brew city chips and homemade tartar sauce.

  • Chicken Strips

    $7.95

    tender beer battered strips of chicken breast served golden brown with your choice of dipping sauce.

  • Finger Steaks

    $8.95

    strips of tender sirloin, beer battered and cooked to a golden brown perfection, served with your choice of dipping sauce. a local favorite.

Island Entrees

  • Hawaiian Chicken

    $10.95

    a tender grilled teriyaki chicken breast topped with a sweet grilled pineapple ring and melting swiss cheese.

  • Top Sirloin

    $13.95

    a 6oz melt in your mouth tender cut, grilled to perfection, and served with your choice of tomato-cilantro sauce, or a delicious peppercorn cream sauce with a hint of cognac.

  • Montego Chicken

    $11.95

    a tender grilled chicken breast topped with a delicious mushroom, jack daniels cream sauce. a delight for your tastes buds!

  • Coconut Crusted Prawns

    $13.95

    4 tender jumbo prawns tossed in a light breading mixed with sweet toasted coconut flakes, presented with a sweet and spicy marmalade sauce.

  • Atlantic Stuffed Salmon

    $9.95

    a generous portion of atlantic salmon stuffed with a red pepper and parmesan stuffing then drizzled with a lemon, caper dill sauce.

  • Island Shrimp Skewers

    $15.95

    21 skewered shrimp lightly basted in butter and dusted with a blend of jamaican jerk seasonings, then grilled to perfection.

  • Cocomo Crab Cakes

    $12.95

    tender crab meat mixed with roasted red, yellow, green peppers, garlic, and a mixture of seasonings drizzled with a creamy hollandaise sauce.

  • Catch Of The Day

    $13.95

    ask your server what the delicious catch of the day is!

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.