Herrell's Renaissance Cafe Menu and Prices

4.3 (424 reviews)13 menu items · 5 categoriesUpdated June 5, 2026

Herrell's Renaissance Cafe is the kind of store you'll want to go in and sit down when you pass by. There are ice cream, coffee, tea, juice shakes, etc., with a wide range of options. If you want to have a cup of cold extract with a sugar cone, or a glass of juice to relieve boredom, you can basically satisfy it. It's not the kind of trendy Internet celebrity store. The atmosphere is relatively relaxed. It's suitable for stopping when you are tired from shopping, or chatting casually with friends.

Sundaes

  • Hot Fudge, Etc

    $0.00

    Your choice of Herrell's own hot fudge (special flavored Hot Fudge, too!), hot penuche (similar to butterscotch), strawberries, raspberries, pineapple, or blueberries

Smoosh-ins

  • Smoosh-in

    $0.00

    Sizes: Regular or Large. Flavors: Any of Herrell's available ice cream, sorbet, or frozen yogurt

Milkshakes & Floats

  • The Choices

    $0.00

    Small Milkshake, Milkshake, Malted milkshake, Orange Milkshake, Double-thick Milkshake, Milkshake Float (An extra scoop of ice cream floating in your milkshake), Ice Cream Soda, Root Beer Float, Cola

Real Fruit Smoothies

  • The Fruit Quartet

    $0.00

    Strawberries, pineapple, bananas, and orange juice

  • Raspberry Tango

    $0.00

    Raspberries, natural apple juice, and vanilla frozen yogurt

  • Mad for Mangos

    $0.00

    Mango, bananas, and natural mango juice

  • The Big Berry Bang

    $0.00

    Strawberries, raspberries, natural apple juice, and vanilla frozen yogurt

  • Tropical Breeze

    $0.00

    Bananas, pineapple, and natural mango juice

Other Items

  • Usually Available

    $0.00

    The Great Brownie Sundae Cake or hot pie a la mode Quadruple Chocolate Sundae (A large sundae with Herrell's Chocolate Pudding ice cream, our hot fudge, real chocolate whipped cream, and chocolate ch

  • Hand-packed Pints & Quarts

    $0.00

    Note that several flavors of our ice cream may be packed in the same container. All strictly fresh!

  • Beverages

    $0.00

    All Herrell's stores carry a variety of coffees, teas, hot chocolate, sodas, and juices. The Allston and Newbury St. Herrell's offer a line of excellent specialty coffees from their full espresso bar

  • Ice Cream Cakes

    $0.00

    Most Herrell's stores make custom ice cream cakes (with our great ice cream!) in various sizes for that special event

  • Novelties

    $0.00

    Some Herrell's stores offer Ice Cream Bon Bons -- various chocolates with Herrell's ice cream inside, in several of our stellar flavors, packaged in attractive gift boxes. Occasionally other items ar

Prices may vary by location. Confirm with the restaurant before ordering.